Finding financing to start and expand a company is an age-old problem, and most
entrepreneurs find it to be one of the greatest struggles they face.
While the process can be time consuming, frus- trating and intimidating, if you
are informed and well prepared, your chances of securing the needed capital are
greatly increased.
In putting together a loan package, ask yourself the following basic questions.
An- swers to them, and the information provided to back up the answers, are essential
to the lending decision and the rapidity with which it is made.
1) What is the specific purpose of the loan? Your lender or investor will review
your fi- nancial requirements among three types of capital acquisition:
* Working Capital. Used to meet fluctuating needs that will be repaid during the
company's next full operating cycle, generally one year.
* Growth Capital. Used to meet needs that will be repaid with profits over a several-
year period (usually not more than seven years). If seeking growth capital, you
will be expected to show how the money will be used to increase profits sufficiently
to repay the loan in the agreed-upon time frame.
* Equity Capital. Used to meet permanent needs. Equity capital must be raised from
investors who will take a risk in return for some combina- tion of dividend returns,
capital gains or a specific share of the business.
2) What amount of financing will support my needs? NOT, how much can I borrow? Have
enough existing capital so that, augmented by the loan, the business can operate
on a sound financial basis. For new businesses, this includes suf- ficient resources
to withstand start-up expenses and the initial operating phase during which losses
are likely to occur. Be able to inject between one-third and one-half of the total
cap- ital required. If you plan to borrow equity from friends or relatives, determine
what the repayment terms will be.
3) When and for how long will I need these funds? Most of today's lenders are providing
growth cap- ital in the form of asset-based loans, i.e., loans for acquiring land,
buildings or equipment which can be used as security. While the majority of these
loans carry terms of three to seven years, some may extend over longer periods.
For finan- cial planning purposes, the entrepreneur should keep in mind that longer
loan periods incur lar- ger overall interest costs.
4) How will I generate sufficient cash flow to re- pay the loan? Consider the situation
from the lender's point of view: if you were asked to lend someone money, you'd
want assurance of being paid back in full, and in a timely manner.
5) What collateral can be utilized, if applicable? Estimate its value, and be ready
to provide sup- porting appraisals.
6) Will the owners provide personal guarantees? Having a comprehensive and well-thought-out
bus- iness plan is essential in obtaining financing. In fact, without one, even
stepping into the bank is pointless. To lenders or potential investors, it not only
provides information and reveals your evaluation of your venture's feasibility,
but also reflects your management abilities. An an- alytical, objective business
plan convinces lend- ers you are cautious, conservative and capable. One that is
poorly researched, or makes unsup- ported assumptions and draws unfounded conclu-
sions, shows you are inexperienced and -- in their eyes -- reckless. Lenders receive
so many proposals that they cannot afford to spend much time evaluating each business
plan. That means your plan has only a few minutes to make a good impression, and
must speak for itself as a sales tool. One key is to make sure your business plan
is as thorough and accurate as possible, and that you can back up all your claims
with facts.
The business plan should include:
* Executive Summary. This portion concisely sum- marizes the key elements of the
business plan which follow, and should convince the lender that it is worthwhile
to review the plan in detail. Include information about the loan being sought in
terms of amount, purpose, duration and how you intend to pay it back.
* Company History/Organization/ Management. De- scribe the historical development
of the business, including legal form of organization, significant changes, subsidiaries
and degree of ownership, and the principals and the role they played in the firm's
foundation. Detail their experience and the management and decision-making structure.
Also include an organizational chart, and discuss other key personnel and their
responsibilities.
* Product/Service. Detail the present or planned product or service lines, including
their rela- tive importance (with sales projections, if pos- sible), evaluation
(use, quality, performance), competitive advantage and demand.
* Market Analysis/Marketing Strategy. You should be able to estimate how many customers
you will have and how near they are to your location, as well as their age, family
structure, lifestyle, disposable income and purchasing habits. Ex- plain why your
product/service is desirable to them, the scope of your firm's marketing and sell-
ing activities (including pricing policy), and what share of the market you will
realistically be able to capture based on the industry analysis that follows.
* Industry Analysis (Competition). It is equal- ly important to know about your
field and have a keen sense of the competition. List your major competitors by name
and describe how closely located they are, what products/services they provide,
what they do better/worse, and how pro- fitable/successful they are. Also elaborate
on the industry itself, including an industry out- look, principal markets, industry
size and major characteristics. Describe the effects of any major social, economic,
technological or regula- tory trends.
* Production/Operating Plan. Explain how the firm will perform production or delivery
of service in terms of physical facilities, sup- pliers, labor supply (current and
planned), technologies/skills required, manufacturing process (if applicable), and
cost breakdown for materials, labor and overhead.
According to George Solomon, Director of Education and Resource Management for the
SBA's Business Development Office, the following items will also be needed to support
a loan request:
* Sources and Uses of Funds Statement. The po- tential lender will require a statement
of how you intend to disperse the loan funds. Back up your statement with supporting
data. For ex- ample, buying a commercial building will require a preliminary title
report, an appraisal, an escrow and title insurance, among other documents.
* Cash Flow Statement (Budget). These documents (used for internal planning) project
what your business means in terms of dollars, and show cash inflow and outflow over
a period of time. If you've been in business for some time, worksheets can be compiled
from the actual figures of income and expenses of previous years combined with pro-
jected changes for the next period. If starting a new business, you will have to
project your financial needs and disbursements.
* Three-Year Income Projection. This pro-forma projection only includes income and
deductible expenses, while the cash flow statement (above) includes all sources
of cash and monies to be paid out. Find out the lender's specific re- quirements
as to whether income and expenses should be projected on an annual or monthly basis.
* Break-Even Analysis. The break-even point is the point at which a company's expenses
exactly match its sales or service volume, and the firm neither makes a profit nor
incurs a loss. It can be calculated in either mathematical or graph form, and expressed
in total dollars or revenue exactly offset by total expenses.
* Balance Sheet. This financial statement, usually prepared at the close of an accounting
period, shows the financial condition of the business as of a fixed date. By regularly
preparing it, you will be able to identify and analyze trends in the financial strength
of your firm and thus implement timely modi- fications.
* Income Statement. In contrast to the bal- ance sheet, this statement shows what
has happened to your venture over a period of time, and is an excellent tool for
assessing your business. It enables you to identify weaknesses in your operation
(such as the timing of an advertising campaign that did not bolster sales as anticipated),
and de- vise more effective ways to run your firm and thereby increase profits.
Similarly, you might examine your income statement to see which months have the
heaviest sales volume, and plan inventory accordingly. Comparison of income statements
from several years will provide an excellent picture of the trends in your business.
As a sole proprietor or principal of a corporation, you may be asked to back up
your business loan with personal assets (your house, stocks or bonds). If you're
in a partnership, a personal guarantee must be signed by all principals for repayment
of the loan.
It is important to emphasize that busi- nesses with several years of successful
opera- tion will find it far easier to obtain financ- ing than start-ups, as lenders
will be much more receptive and confident in your ability to repay a loan at that
point. In fact, with- out a strong business plan with realistic ex- pectations and
forecasts, managerial experience and collateral, it may be impossible for a new
business to get a loan at all. Lenders are always leery of extending financing to
new ven- tures or unproven management teams as they rep- resent a high risk of default.
This doesn't mean you can't get a loan as a start-up, but rather that you will have
to compensate for the lack of a track record by being strong and well prepared in
other areas. Demonstrate by your enthusiasm and the thorough- ness of your business
plan that you are commit- ted to the venture and that it will succeed. After all,
when applying for a loan, you're sell- ing both yourself and your business.
Scott McCrea, a consultant with Deloitte & Touche's San Francisco office, advises
entrepre- neurs to develop and nurture a relationship once credit is granted. He
suggests keeping the lender updated on the company's progress, and staying abreast
of the lender's other products and services that may apply to your business. As
the firm grows, you may need to restructure or enhance your credit, and it only
makes sense to turn to someone already familiar with, and confident in, your business
acumen.
How Banks Evaluate Loan Requests
In putting together the best possible package to secure a business loan, it's important
to know what happens after you leave the bank, and the lending officer evaluates
your request.
But first a word of warning from Roger Bel Air, author of How to Borrow Money from
a Banker and national lecturer: Banks are in business to lend money and get it repaid
-- with interest. That's their number one pri- ority. And several key factors are
contri- buting to heightened cautiousness on their part, including concern about
a greater number of business failures and losses in the face of an economic recession,
and tougher loan exam- ination policies by federal bank regulators as a result of
the savings and loan crisis.
"A banker's career is based on not mak- ing mistakes," Bel Air stresses. "And deter-
mining whether or not the bank will be repaid -- the bottom line in any loan decision
-- is subjective. Beyond the facts and figures alone, banks want to see that the
applicant has thor- oughly reviewed his options, laid the necessary groundwork for
borrowing, and prepared a clearly written and well organized loan appli- cation.
This is particularly true in today's credit-tight market as lending officers feel
a tightening of the screws from regulators, and uncertainty about the future."
Another advantage of preparing an effec- tively organized loan application (including
the all-important business plan) is that it will significantly decrease the time
spent waiting for an answer. According to John Nelson III, SCORE counselor in Rhode
Island and vice presi- dent of a major U.S. bank, "in about 80 percent of the cases,
the formal request is not com- plete." Much of the time spent in approving a loan
can be traced to the banker having to ask the potential borrower for more information
or for clarification of the information that has already been submitted.
In evaluating loan applications, three C's of credit are taken into account -- character,
capacity and collateral.
1. Character. Character is actually a check on your financial status and personal
credit his- tory, including your previous loan payment record. The theory is that
people are creatures of habit -- if you have repaid a loan on time before, you will
repay this one as well. Con- versely, if you have defaulted on a previous loan,
the danger is that you'll tend to default again.
Also considered is experience in the type of business you are trying to finance,
including level of responsibility, education and business management training. Lenders
are particularly concerned that potential borrowers have a solid understanding of
financial record keeping, busi- ness credit, the importance of collecting ac- counts
receivable, inventory control and turn- over, and marketing their product or service.
If your prior business experience is not relevant to your current venture (for example,
if your career has been in the corporate world, and you want to start a restaurant),
banks will be leery about your ability to run the new endeavor successfully and
thus repay the loan.
2. Capacity. Prudent bankers have always looked first to the cash flow of the business
as the way the loan will be repaid, which underlines the importance of preparing
a cash flow state- ment with future cash flow projections before presenting your
loan request. Doing so indi- cates to the lender that you are knowledgable about
the cash coming into your business and being spent, and therefore better able to
avoid a cash shortage that would jeopardize making monthly loan payments.
3. Collateral. While cash flow is the primary source of loan repayment, lenders
will want a back-up or secondary source as an "exit of last resort" should your
business not prove profitable. Collateral -- defined as "anything of value used
as security for repayment of a debt or performance of a contract" -- can be real
estate, stocks and bonds, savings account passbooks, equipment, accounts receivable,
or the cash value of life insurance policies.
Psychologically, lenders feel that bor- rowers have more interest in repaying the
loan if they know that failure to do so will result in the lender taking possession
of whatever has been put up for collateral. A lender will also try to obtain personal
guarantees so that if you default on the loan, the institution has access to your
personal assets.
It's important to note that these days, in the wake of severe economic downturns
such as that experienced in the Southwest in the mid-1980s, collateral doesn't carry
the weight it used to. As the president of an Oklahoma bank stated, "In Oklahoma
City, you can buy a building today for what it cost to rent one eight or nine years
ago." So banks are like- ly to require more collateral than was pre- viously the
case, and evaluate it based on market -- rather than replacement -- value. Companies
without enough collateral to pledge will have to scale back their borrowing needs
and make do with less.
One final tip is not to forget "relation- ship banking." Once a relationship has
been established, and you've explained your business operations and anticipated
needs, it becomes far easier to approach a banker when a loan is needed. This familiarity
will make you more credible than a customer who has not taken the time to introduce
himself.
And be sure to stay close to your banker, being open and honest about major changes
and significant events -- both good and bad. Be- cause your lending officer has
to tell your story to other people in the organization (in- cluding his superiors),
nothing can jinx the relationship faster than a lack of candor. Feeding bankers
regular information is, of course, time consuming when you have a com- pany to run.
But it's all part of building credibility and trust, and will enable you to use
your banker's knowledge to help ensure the continued success of your business.